Statement of Purpose Feedback: Why You Should Seek It -

Philippe Barr, PhD
8 min readJul 6, 2023

Why should you get statement of purpose feedback? Here is the tea:

Graduate students often feel intimidated by the prospect of writing a statement of purpose, the crucial document that can make or break their admission to graduate school. This one document is designed to encapsulate everything that makes you a unique and valuable addition to a program. The statement of purpose is essentially a personal essay, where the student must demonstrate their passion and commitment to their field of study while convincing the admissions committee that they are a deserving candidate. Needless to say, constructing a strong statement of purpose is no small feat, but it’s one that all grad school applicants must conquer if they hope to get into their program of choice. However, writing a statement of purpose can be a challenging task, especially for students who may lack confidence in their writing skills.

Feedback is a necessary component of the writing process, and the SOP is no exception. It is essential to receive feedback from someone who can assess your essay from a position of knowledge and experience. This blog post delves into the importance of feedback on your statement of purpose, how it can positively impact your writing process, and how to get the most out of it.

Before seeking statement of purpose feedback

Choose the Right People

Not all feedback is created equal. It’s important to choose people who are knowledgeable about the graduate school application process and who can provide you with constructive criticism. Seek out professors, mentors, or professionals who have experience in your field or who have insight into the application process. They can offer valuable insights into what admissions committees are looking for and how you can improve your statement of purpose.

Understand the purpose of your statement of Purpose

Before you seek feedback on your statement of purpose, it’s important to understand its purpose. Your statement of purpose should communicate your goals, your passion for your chosen field, and your fit with the program you’re applying to. It’s not just about listing your accomplishments or providing a summary of your resume. Keep this in mind when you seek feedback, and ask your reviewers to focus on these key elements.

Here’s how getting the right feedback can benefit you:

Identify weaknesses

Let’s face it — we’re all a little biased towards ourselves. Even if we try to be objective, it can be tough to see our own shortcomings. This is where constructive criticism comes in. An experienced and skilled reader can identify errors such as unclear and ambiguous writing, grammatical errors, weak arguments, or underdeveloped points. Feedback from someone else can be just what you need to point out some of the weaknesses in your statement of purpose. This allows you to address the issues and make changes that could make a significant difference in the way your statement is received.

Avoid common mistakes

Writing a strong statement of purpose can be tricky, especially since you may not be familiar with the specific requirements and preferences of each graduate program. Feedback from experienced professionals can be invaluable in this context, as it can help you identify and correct common mistakes that can make your essays weaker or even disqualify you from acceptance.

For example, feedback can help you avoid generic or clichéd language, irrelevant information, poor organization, weak arguments, and overused quotes or anecdotes. Moreover, feedback can help you tailor your essays to the specific program you are applying to, by highlighting the key features or initiatives that appeal to you and align with your academic goals.

Improve clarity and effectiveness

The goal of feedback is to help you improve. There should be no shame in getting edits on a document — even if it feels a bit like having a spotlight shined on your flaws! At the end of the day, having someone point out ways to make your statement better is an opportunity to improve your application. This is something that can pay off tremendously in the end.

Another benefit of statement of purpose feedback is that it can help you improve your writing skills and style. Many students struggle with expressing their ideas clearly and persuasively, and feedback can provide concrete examples and suggestions for improvement.

Feedback can also help you with word choice, tone, syntax, formatting, and grammar, which are all essential aspects of creating a compelling essay. By learning from the feedback you receive, you can not only improve your statement of purpose but also your overall communication skills, which will be invaluable in your academic and professional careers.

Confidence boost and peace of mind

Writing a statement of purpose can be intimidating, and feedback can help to boost your confidence. Often, writing is a solitary exercise, and writers are unsure if their writing is on track. Feedback from someone experienced can make all the difference, giving you the assurance that your essay is well-written and on point. Feedback can help alleviate uncertainty and anxiety, by offering clear and constructive guidance that you can trust.

On the flip side of improvement, feedback can be uplifting. When you receive positive feedback about a particular aspect of your statement of purpose, it can give you the confidence boost you need to keep pushing forward. Not only can it make you feel good, but it can help you see where your strengths lie, and how you can best showcase those strengths in your statement.

Fresh and objective perspective

Feedback from someone from a different background or profession can offer new insights into your essay. Perhaps you’re a science major applying for an English program; the insights provided by an experienced professional in the field could help shape your writing and bring more clarity to the statement of purpose’s structure.

Constructive feedback is also valuable because it enables you to see your statement of purpose from a different perspective. It’s easy to get mired down in what you believe is essential to include and forget that someone else may see things differently. Having another person review your document can give you the chance to see what stands out and what falls flat. Sometimes, someone else can see something glaringly obvious that you would have never noticed.

Getting feedback on your statement of purpose allows a fresh pair of eyes to analyze your work and provide unbiased opinions for improvement. Objective feedback means being open to all forms of feedback, even if it is something you may not want to hear. Feedback gives you, the applicant, a chance to revise and improve your essay.

Enhanced Language

The content of your statement of purpose could be great, but if your grammar is poor or your structure is disorganized, it can detract from your work. Having someone else review your work can help ensure that your statement of purpose is structurally sound, grammatically correct, and easy to read.

Feedback can help you refine your writing style. Often, your writing might be technically good with accurate grammar and correct syntax, but that doesn’t mean your statement of purpose will be effective. Feedback can help refine your language, ensuring maximum impact and conveyance of your ideas.

Extra edge

In graduate school admissions, it’s often the little things that make a difference. Constructive feedback can help you stand out from the rest of the pack by giving your statement the extra edge it needs. Getting feedback from individuals who have years of experience reviewing applications is incredibly valuable. Taking their insights to heart can make a tangible difference in your statement and increase your chances of acceptance.

Be open-minded and receptive to feedback.

It can be challenging to receive feedback on your writing, especially if you have invested a lot of time and effort. However, it is crucial to listen to the feedback and be open-minded. Approach feedback as an opportunity to improve your writing. Listen carefully to the feedback and take notes. Also, ask for clarification if you do not understand any feedback. Remember, the goal is to improve your statement of purpose and increase your chances of being accepted to your dream school.

Incorporate constructive feedback thoughtfully.

Once you have received feedback, take the time to review and incorporate it carefully. Highlight the areas that need improvement, and make the necessary changes. Use the feedback as a guide to enhance your writing, but make sure that the statement of purpose remains in your own voice and reflects your motivations and aspirations. Remember to focus on the content and meaning of your statement of purpose — not just grammar and syntax.

Revise and edit before submitting.

After incorporating the feedback, take the time to revise and edit your statement of purpose before submitting it. Double-check for grammar and spelling errors, as they can detract from the content of your writing. It’s a good idea to have someone else, such as a professor or advisor, review your statement before submission.

Practice makes perfect.

Finally, remember that improving your writing skills and receiving feedback is an ongoing process. Accept that you might not get everything right on your first try, but make a conscious effort to develop your writing skills over time.

Conclusion

In addition to a strong GPA, a strong GRE score, and a strong resume, a well-written statement of purpose can make a significant difference in the outcome of your graduate school application, so do not underestimate the power of feedback. It may be tough at first to receive critical feedback, but this is an opportunity to make a great impression on the admission panel and show that you are eager to learn, grow, and improve. Don’t be afraid to share your document with others and get feedback. It can only help you in the end. Seeing things from a different angle, identifying weaknesses, allowing for improvement, gaining confidence, and standing out are all ways that constructive feedback can elevate your statement of purpose. Got questions? Sign up for a consultation, or send us your draft for an estimate. It’s FREE!

With a Master’s from McGill University and a Ph.D. from New York University, Dr. Philippe Barr is the founder of The Admit Lab. As a tenure-track professor, Dr. Barr spent a decade teaching and serving on several graduate admission committees at UNC-Chapel Hill before turning to full-time consulting. With more than seven years of experience as a graduate school admissions consultant, Dr. Barr has stewarded the candidate journey across multiple master’s and Ph.D. programs and helped hundreds of students get admitted to top-tier graduate programs all over the world.

Follow me on Instagram and TikTok for tips and tricks on navigating the grad school application process and weekly live Q&A sessions!

Originally published at https://admit-lab.com on July 6, 2023.

--

--

Philippe Barr, PhD

I am Philippe Barr, founder of The Admit Lab, a graduate school admissions consultancy that helps students get admitted into grad school: https://admit-lab.com/